Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
A new musical comedy about two strangers who meet on the streets of New York City when Robin agrees to help Dougal carry a cake across town. As they navigate the city together, unexpected connection and romance bloom in this charming, laugh-filled love story celebrating chance encounters and the magic of New York.
Critic Reviews
16 reviewsCalls it an effervescent, charmingly simple new musical comedy that delivers classic rom-com laughter, escape, and fantasy.
Says the piece comes alive when it leans into wistful, specific feelings rather than the love story.
Singles out Tutty as a dazzling newcomer with appealing looks, pure voice, and strong comic instincts.
Focuses on how much fun the evening is thanks to the score, witty lyrics, and lead performances.
Credits the show for balancing rom-com cliches with sharp left turns and nuanced commentary about connection.
Cast
- Sam TuttyDougal
- Christiani PittsRobin
Creative Team
- Jim BarneMusic & Lyrics
- Kit BuchanBook
- Tim JacksonDirector & Choreographer
Details
- Opened
- Nov 20, 2025
- Runtime
- 2h 15m
- Intermissions
- 1
- Age
- Ages 12+
